Skip to content
Case Result

Federal Judge Orders Defendants to Be Imprisoned Until They Pay the Settlement

On October 8, 2026, after a three-hour hearing, Judge Algenon L. Marbley of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio ordered three strip club owners and operators to be taken into federal custody. They will remain in custody until they pay what they owe under a class action settlement that Andy Biller of Biller & Kimble and our co-counsel Paul De Marco of Markovits, Stock & DeMarco obtained on behalf of a group of exotic dancers and bartenders. The judge said it was only the second time he has sent someone to jail for civil contempt. Andy Biller argued the case on behalf of the dancers. (614NOW coverage of the arrests; court minute entry.)

Background

In 2015, Andy Biller filed this lawsuit (Hogan v. Cleveland Avenue Restaurant, Inc., No. 2:15-cv-2883) on behalf of a group of exotic dancers at Sirens, a Columbus strip club. The allegations challenged a common strip club industry practice: dancers pay “rent,” “house fees,” or other charges to work at a club. The dancers alleged that they should have been treated as employees and paid at least minimum wage.

The Settlement

In February 2019, Sirens agreed to settle the dancers’ and bartenders’ claims for $600,000, to be paid at $8,000 per month.

Shortly after the Court approved the settlement, the defendants stopped making payments. As a result, the Court appointed a Special Master (authorized under the settlement agreement) to oversee the defendants and ensure they made their settlement payments. Over the years, the defendants fell further and further behind. In February 2025, Judge Marbley ordered the defendants to resume payments or potentially face contempt of court.

By November 2025, Sirens’ owners and manager (Francis Sharrak, Michael Sharrak, and Jay Nelson) had stopped making payments altogether.

Our Efforts to Enforce the Settlement

For the past year, we and our co-counsel Mr. De Marco relentlessly pursued the defendants to continue funding the settlement. The Court held multiple “show cause” hearings, giving the Sirens defendants every opportunity to explain themselves and pay what they owed.

These hearings culminated in a July 1 hearing where the Sirens defendants claimed they could pay what they owed (about $250,000 at the time) within ten days. If they did not, they understood that the judge could put them in jail.

The October 8, 2026 Hearing

At the October 8 hearing, we (along with Special Counsel appointed to assist the Special Master) argued that the Sirens defendants were in contempt of court and should be jailed until they pay the settlement. After a three-hour hearing, Judge Marbley agreed that the Sirens defendants had given him no choice but to imprison them until they comply with the Court’s orders. The U.S. Marshals took immediate custody of the defendants and escorted them from the courtroom. On October 14, 2026, the Court issued a written order confirming that the defendants will remain in custody until they pay $240,891.82 toward the settlement or show in detail that they cannot pay.

Although we believe this sanction was a long time coming, we don’t write to celebrate the defendants’ imprisonment. From Andy: “I don’t relish the idea of anyone going to jail, and I know the judge doesn’t either. Unfortunately, the defendants left us with little choice but to coerce their compliance with imprisonment. The defendants can leave prison anytime they choose: they just have to pay the money that they promised to the dancers.”

Imprisonment for civil contempt is rare, and it should be. It is what remains when lesser orders have been ignored and the money has not been paid. We will keep pushing until the class is paid. That, not anyone’s confinement, was the point of the hearing. Our hope is that this will encourage the Sirens defendants to promptly pay what they owe to our clients.

Back to the blog →

Think you have a claim?

Contact (513) 202-0710